comps suggestions .. choices:dyn,morel,elite,polk&focal

Need help with your car stereo system? Have a technical question? Post here.
eyesofra
Posts: 613
Joined: Wed Feb 28, 2007 11:41 pm
Location: from Cameron Highlands MY to ACT AU
Contact:

Post by eyesofra »

martinkruit wrote: But when you filter (24 db) the sub at 150 hz the minus 3 db point will be at 167.5 Hz. then you can filter your mid at 200 hz. in that case the minus 3 db point is also at 167.5 Hz. combined the two minus 3 db point will give a boost off +3 db, so your frequence responce will be flat.
this is really cool understanding how it works.
The only thing that i'm not so clear is the 200Hz part.
If we use the same 24db xover then wouldn't the -3db point be somewhere higher then 167.5Hz or closer to the 200Hz.

If i understand correctly,in order for both the -3dbs to meet the 200Hz has to be reduced to like 185Hz or by applying a less steeper xover and stay at 200Hz.

I could be completely wrong with this, but just trying to figure out here...
" If u know the rules, then u can break them " - Vidal S
User avatar
MINI COOP
Manneken Pis
Posts: 192
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 12:44 pm
Location: Veldegem

Post by MINI COOP »

hmmm I understand what you're saying martin, but I still have my doubts about it. some filters and a spectrum analyser should solve this problems offcourse, because then you can examine both filters (a 24db/oct and an 12db/oct)...

@ eyesofra: yep, it's what martin said, because I put the sub in the thrunk (like most people do?!) I must play with my active filters. 18db/oct was the best filtering that I could do to match the sub with the speakers :wink:
some white pg shit in my thrunk, love it!
eyesofra
Posts: 613
Joined: Wed Feb 28, 2007 11:41 pm
Location: from Cameron Highlands MY to ACT AU
Contact:

Post by eyesofra »

MINI COOP wrote:
@ eyesofra: yep, it's what martin said, because I put the sub in the thrunk (like most people do?!) I must play with my active filters. 18db/oct was the best filtering that I could do to match the sub with the speakers :wink:
how do u determine the matching phase man , do u use any analyzers or purely by listening ?
" If u know the rules, then u can break them " - Vidal S
User avatar
martinkruit
Posts: 429
Joined: Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:06 am
Location: The Netherlands

Post by martinkruit »

eyesofra wrote:
martinkruit wrote: But when you filter (24 db) the sub at 150 hz the minus 3 db point will be at 167.5 Hz. then you can filter your mid at 200 hz. in that case the minus 3 db point is also at 167.5 Hz. combined the two minus 3 db point will give a boost off +3 db, so your frequence responce will be flat.
this is really cool understanding how it works.
The only thing that i'm not so clear is the 200Hz part.
If we use the same 24db xover then wouldn't the -3db point be somewhere higher then 167.5Hz or closer to the 200Hz.

If i understand correctly,in order for both the -3dbs to meet the 200Hz has to be reduced to like 185Hz or by applying a less steeper xover and stay at 200Hz.

I could be completely wrong with this, but just trying to figure out here...
You're right, to get at the -3dB at 167.5 you have to start at a different frequence

For the phase off the sub, just listen. :D
User avatar
MINI COOP
Manneken Pis
Posts: 192
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 12:44 pm
Location: Veldegem

Post by MINI COOP »

eyesofra wrote:
MINI COOP wrote:
@ eyesofra: yep, it's what martin said, because I put the sub in the thrunk (like most people do?!) I must play with my active filters. 18db/oct was the best filtering that I could do to match the sub with the speakers :wink:
how do u determine the matching phase man , do u use any analyzers or purely by listening ?
I use a track from a sq competition disk (in the benelux: EMMA SQ). this track goes from 20khz to 20hz. my frontsystem goes from about 70-80hz to 20khz, the sub goes from 100 to 20hz.

when your system is not in phase you will hear that the subbas will go to the thrunk (because, there he's located :wink: ), so the stage of the music lays not completely in the front.

If your phase is good, you will hear that the subbas stays in the front...

offcourse listen to music to, you will hear that the kickbas & bas wil be a lot smoother when the speakers are exactly in phase :wink:
some white pg shit in my thrunk, love it!
User avatar
martinkruit
Posts: 429
Joined: Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:06 am
Location: The Netherlands

Post by martinkruit »

MINI COOP wrote:
eyesofra wrote:
MINI COOP wrote:
@ eyesofra: yep, it's what martin said, because I put the sub in the thrunk (like most people do?!) I must play with my active filters. 18db/oct was the best filtering that I could do to match the sub with the speakers :wink:
how do u determine the matching phase man , do u use any analyzers or purely by listening ?
I use a track from a sq competition disk (in the benelux: EMMA SQ). this track goes from 20khz to 20hz. my frontsystem goes from about 70-80hz to 20khz, the sub goes from 100 to 20hz.

when your system is not in phase you will hear that the subbas will go to the thrunk (because, there he's located :wink: ), so the stage of the music lays not completely in the front.

If your phase is good, you will hear that the subbas stays in the front...

offcourse listen to music to, you will hear that the kickbas & bas wil be a lot smoother when the speakers are exactly in phase :wink:
On the listening position.............................
Post Reply